Paul D. Eden
peden at americanphysicians.net
Thu Sep 2 09:47:06 EDT 2004
> What I believe is more important, whatever the candidate project may be, is that > a single initial set of mock up web pages be developed by someone who is good at > web design and that everyone use these as a starting point. In other words, the > final design of each implementation should look more or less the same to the user. > The only thing that should really change is the underlying implementation which > supports it. If the user facing interface is always the same, it would make it easier > for someone evaluating the different implementations to see how each differs. > If everyone were free to come up with totally different page designs and features, > would be much harder to compare. > > Thus, start with raw HTML mock up pages which could be viewed statically with > some dummy data. PSP people could take that and convert them into PSP. The > mpservlet people could convert them to their way of doing things, similarly for > Albatross etc etc. > > Someone evalulating it can then look at how a particular static HTML page gets > translated into a dynamic page in a particular implementation. > > BTW, there may need to be two reference HTML designs. One for old style HTML > table driven approaches and one for CSS driven designs where HTML tables aren't > used for layout. This may be appropriate as different implementation methods > may be biased towards one or the other. The mock up pages is a great idea. I had the luxury of having full-time designers to work with at a company before. We new what it was to look like and then we make it work, it is it applicable to real-world business apps. It will also make comparison between submissions easier. Paul Eden peden at americanphysicians dot net
|